Alienation, Labor, and Capitalist Power in Herman Melville’s Bartleby, the Scrivener: A Marxist Critical Analysis
This paper provides the Marxist critical analysis of Bartleby, the Scrivener by Herman Melville with its dramatizing of the themes of alienation, labor exploitation, and capitalist power being experienced by the character of Bartleby and the bureaucratic setting he works in. The work applies the theory of alienated labor developed by Karl Marx, and adopts the perspectives of Althusser, Lukacs and Marcuse to analyze how passive resistance of Bartleby, who replied incessantly, “I would prefer not to,” demonstrates the psychological and material implications of the capitalist ideology. The monotonous clerical work, the strict order of classes, and the incapability of the narrator to see the humanity within Bartleby described in the story predict the dehumanizing nature of the capitalist order. This paper has attempted to make a case by close textual analysis to argue that Bartleby is a kind of alienated worker who isolates him/herself in a system that cannot provide emotional, social, and existential satisfaction. His retreat ends up revealing the ethical sterility of the capitalistic system and the lack of possibility of authentic human interaction in the same. The study has added to the Melville studies in both placing Bartleby into a wider context of critique of capitalism in the nineteenth century and showing how Melville prefigures contemporary interpretations of labor, resistance, and ideological control.